Active 5 days ago
Estimating could include material take-offs for simple quantities or complex pricing. Whether you count... View more
Estimating could include material take-offs for simple quantities or complex pricing. Whether you count occupancy loads or widgets this is the place to connect.
Are you sure you want to leave ?
Linear Footage of Saw Cutting
Linear Footage of Saw CuttingPosted by Matt Hackman on May 17, 2022 at 1:50 pm
Working on slab demolition and wondering if anyone has worked out a way to calculate linear feet of saw cutting needed if I want the specified area to be broken up into 2’x2′ squares?
MemberMay 17, 2022 at 5:15 pmPoints: 11,498Rank: UC2 Brainery Blue Belt I
I can’t see anyway that a formula can be used so my only suggestion is to draw up some grids using the poly lengths at 2′ centres – maybe make a few up with different overall shapes and sizes. Group these lengths together and save as a tool.
Then when required lay the grid over your slab area, ungroup it and make the fine tuning adjustments to suit the actual shape.
Not ideal but this may save some time compared to starting afresh each time.
MemberMay 18, 2022 at 11:09 amPoints: 2,250Rank: UC2 Brainery Yellow Belt IIII
Thanks for the response, I may end up doing what you said as I’ve been drawing the lines every time but having them spaced out already will cut down on some of the time for sure.
MemberMay 19, 2022 at 8:28 amPoints: 22,418Rank: UC2 Brainery Brown Belt II
This might be a good example of where a “trim” feature would be handy to have. Imagine being able to drop your pre-arranged 2×2 grid over an irregular shape and then being able to draw a “trimming line” around the limits of the area to be cut. Could be a huge timesaver!
MemberMay 20, 2022 at 8:59 amPoints: 11,498Rank: UC2 Brainery Blue Belt I
The other thing I tried to do was to draw a shape with a cut out then ‘fill’ that void with the grid – no luck!
MemberMay 18, 2022 at 9:42 amPoints: 22,418Rank: UC2 Brainery Brown Belt II
Interesting question @matt-hackman
Not knowing the shape of what you are looking at I made a quick calc. Starting with a simple 10 ft x 10 ft square (100 SF) cutting 1 boundary edge (say north side and west side) and every 2 feet in both directions you would end up with 100 lf of saw cutting (50 lf north-south, 50 lf east-west). So, in this case, if you measured the square footage it would be a 1 to 1 relationship between square footage and saw cutting. You would need to add an additional boundary cut on one side north south and east west.
MemberMay 18, 2022 at 11:11 amPoints: 2,250Rank: UC2 Brainery Yellow Belt IIII
Thanks for the response, I, unfortunately, haven’t run into a slab being demoed that’s square too often. I might try looking into excel formulas. I do have OST access so I have the option of uploading a single sheet and calculating just the saw cutting in there.
OrganizerMay 18, 2022 at 11:45 amPoints: 20,343Rank: UC2 Brainery Brown Belt
Formulas were my first response, you need a custom column for the cut spacing, then another one to divide height by spacing plus width divided by spacing. This works great for square slabs, however now that you say slabs are rarely square this wouldn’t work because the width and height of the markup isn’t an accurate value when not square with the sheet. I’ve built very similar custom columns to calculate rebar, but it has it’s limitations.
MemberMay 18, 2022 at 11:53 amPoints: 11,498Rank: UC2 Brainery Blue Belt I
I tried a quick couple of calculations from different sizes of squares & rectangles, although the results were reasonable accurate on some they were way out on others. I would imagine this variance will just grow with irregular shapes.
MemberJune 14, 2022 at 1:30 pmPoints: 11,790Rank: UC2 Brainery Blue Belt I
wouldn’t the formula be something like – ((number of 2 x 2 blocks * 4) + width + height)
Assuming each 2 x 2 square will be cut on at least one width and one height and the attached 2 x 2 square will complete the cut. Then the additional width and height will complete all the cuts.
MemberJune 14, 2022 at 2:49 pmPoints: 11,498Rank: UC2 Brainery Blue Belt I
Unfortunately, it depends on the configuration e.g. if you use a simple example of just four blocks in square and rectangular configurations formulas don’t appear to work. Once you get into much larger and irregular shapes then the discrepancies between formula results and the actual lengths grows.
MemberJune 15, 2022 at 5:49 amPoints: 22,418Rank: UC2 Brainery Brown Belt II
This might be worth trying @matt-hackman
1. Starting with a grid draw a series of 1 ft horizontal and vertical “sawcut” lines. Maybe start with a 10 X 10 grid
2. Select them all and group them together
3. Add this group as a custom tool
4. Paste this group over your area as needed
5. Select and ungroup your markup
6. Select the pieces that fall outside your cut demo area and delete them.
7. Select all again and group the remaining pieces.
A lot comes down to how accurate you want to be. You could work with 6” long segments or 5 ft. You could also extend or add filler pieces to dial it in.
MemberJune 15, 2022 at 7:38 amPoints: 22,418Rank: UC2 Brainery Brown Belt II
I tried this once I got in front of my computer this morning and it seems as if it could work well with some refinement @matt-hackman
A couple of additional notes:
1. Draw you sawcut gridlines in 1 ft (or smaller) segments of one perimeter measurement (polyline may work also). You can then “split all” to get the individual segments.
2. Draw you grid line once and then copy paste it to increase your grid size. Once you have a 10 ft x 10 ft grid copy that group and replicate it quickly to cover large areas.
3. Leave the bottom and right side piece out so that when you place your duplicate group next to it you don’t double up on the matching edge.
4. The “lasso” tool works great for selecting the segments that you want to remove (thank you @Vince for introducing me to this tool!), though it takes a bit of practice.
Curious to hear what everyone thinks of this idea/how it can be improved!😎
MemberJune 26, 2022 at 1:51 amPoints: 11,498Rank: UC2 Brainery Blue Belt I
I’ve been look at creating grids for something else then came up with this….
Create your 2’x2′ template grid in a new document covering the biggest area that you’ll need – cover an A1 piece of paper if needed. Use individual Polylines – this should only take a few minutes.
If you use group to make to copy & paste when drawing your template then make sure everything is ungrouped when you finish.
Then to use: –
1. Copy the whole template page into the document you are working on.
2. Go to the area you are wanting to measure and use “Spaces” and draw around the area that you are looking at.
3. Copy the space and paste it onto your grid instead of trying to put the grid onto your shape.
4. Move the space around to get the best fit on your grid.
5. Go to your mark-ups list and sort by spaces and then select the space that you are working on.
That should be it – 2′ long lengths that are fully captured in the space will be totalled in the mark-up list. This should be the only item within that space so the mark-up list will give you the total length of all the 2’s.
No need for cutting, stretching or deleting of the grid. You can of course make adjustments to the shape of the Space to include any additional 2′ lengths to your measures or you can move the whole shape slightly to see what difference that makes.
Still not 100% accurate but should hopefully get you near enough.
Alternatively, you can go for a slightly more ‘destructive’ route. You will need to know the total length of all the 2′ segments in your grid to start with for this one.
1. Copy the whole template page into the document you are working on.
2. Either use an area mark-up or spaces to copy the shape of the area that you want to measure.
3. Paste the shape onto your grid.
4. Use the lasso tool to trace around your shape – this will select any of the grid line that even partly fall with your area.
5. Delete the selected lines.
6. Deducted the resulting total length of gridlines from your original total to obtain the total length deleted.
This method obviously doesn’t allow for any manipulation or fine tuning though.
MemberJune 26, 2022 at 2:11 amPoints: 11,498Rank: UC2 Brainery Blue Belt I
Actually, on the 2nd version, don’t delete the lines!
Just rename the subject and change the attributes – maybe make the lines thicker and a different colour so they are easily identifiable.
This way you can then make adjustments if you want to.
To get the total of the lines just sort the mark-up table for whatever you have called the selected lines.
MemberJuly 5, 2022 at 1:01 pmPoints: 2,250Rank: UC2 Brainery Yellow Belt IIII
@Vince I just saw your LinkedIn video and it was super helpful to see this in the video and may do this in the future!
MemberJuly 5, 2022 at 1:25 pmPoints: 11,498Rank: UC2 Brainery Blue Belt I
Hi @Matt. Glad you found the video helpful!
One bit of advice – when setting up your grid start off by using the ‘sketch to scale’ and copy a few of these across to set up the basic grid. You can then draw your ‘perimeter’ lines over these. This way you can make sure your grid spacings are exact. From there you can copy & paste the perimeter lines to fill out the rest of the page.
MemberJuly 20, 2022 at 10:01 pmPoints: 4,481Rank: UC2 Brainery Orange Belt III
I don’t know how accurate you need to be. Real life says that what you planned in the office won’t happen in the field. All the calculations will result in an answer of approximately 1 lf of saw cut per 1 sf of slab, given a 2′ x 2′ grid. The larger the slab the closer it will become as slab edges become less in proportion to slab area.
MemberJuly 21, 2022 at 5:35 amPoints: 22,418Rank: UC2 Brainery Brown Belt II
That’s a very good point @dhwalkellc . Sometimes I wonder if I’m spending too much time getting to the closest foot on items that we are then going to total up and round to the nearest pipe length.
OrganizerJuly 26, 2022 at 4:44 pmPoints: 20,343Rank: UC2 Brainery Brown Belt
I’ve built tools for customers before who wanted to round each length to the pipe length, then total after that. It makes sense so you don’t end up with (30) 1′-0″ sections pasted together for the last section. Like always, start with the end in mind, in this case, how materials are purchased.
Log in to reply.